Welcome from Delaware, Steve! Good to hear that you are already up and running with a first smoke success! You will find the #2 works well in cold weather as well. Cheers
I would go with the #2. I have a #2 analog (about 11 years old now) and I got the rib rack that fits in the smoker. With the rib rack, I can smoke 3.5 racks of BB ribs (cut in half) and get rave reviews!
I would also suggest BB ribs for the first smoke ... it's a nice 5-6 hour smoke that will give the #2 a good run. I usually set the smoker to 235F, and I do remove the ribs at 4 hours to apply some BBQ sauce, then back in the #2 for another 1.5 hours. As for wood, 4oz would be a good...
I currently use the Thermoworks SMOKE thermometer that has one probe for the box temp and one for the meat. It is usually about $100, but it looks like it might be on sale right now. I really like this product. https://www.thermoworks.com/smoke/
I have also used the Maverick ET-72 (I...
I have a #2, so my experiences may be different. When I do BB ribs, I smoke at 235-240F for 5.5 hours and get meat that falls off the bones results every time. I take them out at 4 hours and sauce them up, but they are definitely not ready at that point. Another 1.5 hours back in the smoker...
Congratulations on your first smoke -- and by all indications, a successful one! The ham and bacon pics are making my mouth water! I think you are up and running now! Cheers