14 Hr, 14.5 lb brisket?

DrNoci

New member
Put a brisket on last night thinking it would be done at lunch today, but it was done in 14 hours. My cook was 175 for 2 hours, 200 for 2 hours and 225 for the remaining. Given the 1-1/2 hr/lb estimate I didn’t think there was any chance for that to happen. First time I’ve tried any brisket but this was Wagyu. Has anyone seen a cook time difference in this beef?
 
I had the same experience with a 16 pound Wagyu brisket. I put it on at 11 PM before I went to bed thinking it would be done in the afternoon and I could let it rest until dinner. I wrapped it in butcher paper at about 9 AM when the temp was in the 180's. Checked the temp at noon at it was already 205. Didn't think that could be right so I let it go another hour a pulled it off when it read 210 (too much). Let it rest and it was over cooked, but edible. I find that the times are way off even though the smoker temp is right on the money. Ribs that took 3 hours in my Cookshack take 2 hours in this at the same temp. I'm baffled and thinking of going back to another Cookshack.
 
It was just a suggestion. Some folks have found it necessary. Not sure why. And the controller manufacturer explains the procedure. But if you are getting good results, don't tinker with it. Just enjoy.
 
Back
Top