Don't get me wrong, both butts were tender and juicy. We have been eating it for the past two days and my wife can't get enough of it. I personally am a bit too hard on myself at times in terms of expectations. I do have to say, even when I reheat, it is still tender and juicy.
Now for tomorrow, I'm going to have to change it up, I'm thinking a half pound grilled beef burger, topped with half pound pulled pork, bacon and grilled onions. Just what the doctor ordered (me to not eat).