I did a metric crap ton of research before settling in on the Smokin-It. Initially I was planning to get a Cookshack but the deeper I dug, the less it seemed to worth the premium vs the Smokin-It. I'm glad to see from a Cookshack owner that the two are fairly comparable. If I had the cash for the top of line models, then the Cookshack might be worth it since it has a more advanced thermostat and can be set to cook to an internal temp. But for the money I feel my #3 was a screaming bargain.