Welcome, Ted! I went with the #2 and have never regretted it. I have to cut ribs and generally prefer to cut briskets, though I have just stuffed them in, too. If you're going to smoke large quantities and/or don't ever want to cut and have the budget/space then go with the 3D. If you don't want/need that much real estate, want something more compact, and/or a lower price then the 2D will work really well for you.