I have bought the wild cherry from smokinlicious, and it is good. I think the differences might be subtle. Some things I've heard is that Wild Cherry can have a more bitter taste. I think that's nonsense (and so do a lot of other people). Others say you should not smoke with orchard wood since the trees might have been treated with various chemicals over the years. I don't worry about this too much. I think you will find half of the people say one thing, and half say the other. If you are ordering from Fruitawood, then I would get the one they like best, which is the orchard or sweet cherry. I don't hear many negative opinions about orchard cherry.